Does USPS's Legal Shield Cover Deliberate Mail Slowdowns? Supreme Court Set to Decide

Bitget App

Trade smarter

Bitget

News

Markets

Does USPS's Legal Shield Cover Deliberate Mail Slowdowns? Supreme Court Set to Decide

Bitget-RWA2025/11/26 21:14

By:Bitget-RWA

- U.S. Supreme Court to decide if USPS's FTCA immunity covers intentional mail delays in Lebene Konan's case. - Konan claims employees withheld her mail for 24 months due to racial bias; Fifth Circuit ruled intentional acts are not exempt. - USPS warns a ruling for Konan could trigger lawsuits over minor issues, increasing legal risks and costs. - Case highlights accountability concerns amid reliance on mail for critical transactions like medical supplies and legal documents. - Decision expected in 2026 ma

The U.S. Supreme Court is preparing to take up a significant legal dispute concerning the U.S. Postal Service's (USPS) protection from lawsuits related to mishandled mail, following a two-year legal battle brought by Texas landlord Lebene Konan. This case, which has attracted widespread attention from legal scholars and lawmakers, focuses on whether the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) postal exemption applies when postal workers are accused of intentionally failing to deliver mail. Konan, who works in real estate and insurance, alleges that two USPS employees in Euless, Texas, purposefully withheld her mail for two years, motivated by racial bias and prejudice against property owners.

The outcome could alter the boundaries of federal agency responsibility

and potentially change how the postal service is held accountable in court.

The heart of the dispute is the interpretation of the FTCA's postal exemption, which protects the USPS from being sued for "loss, miscarriage, or negligent transmission" of mail. Konan's attorneys contend that this protection should not extend to deliberate wrongdoing, such as the alleged intentional labeling of her mail as "undeliverable" or "return to sender."

A federal district court originally threw out her lawsuit under this exemption

, but in 2024, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit overturned that ruling,

finding that the case involved purposeful conduct

rather than an ordinary mistake. The appellate court pointed out that the exemption's wording does not specifically rule out claims based on intentional inaction by postal staff.

Does USPS's Legal Shield Cover Deliberate Mail Slowdowns? Supreme Court Set to Decide image 0

The USPS has expressed concern that a decision favoring Konan could result in a wave of lawsuits over mail delays, even for minor or questionable complaints. Frederick Liu, who serves as assistant to the Solicitor General, argued during the hearing that the government's stance is not about "fearmongering" but about avoiding unnecessary lawsuits over routine postal matters.

He referenced hypothetical examples

- such as a postal worker withholding mail because of a "rude comment" or the presence of a "large dog at the door" - to demonstrate how the system could be misused. Justice Samuel Alito shared these worries,

raising the question of whether a sweeping decision could result

in much higher postage fees to offset legal risks.

Konan's lawyers, on the other hand, challenge the idea of a flood of lawsuits. Her attorney, Easha Anand, maintained that cases like Konan's are unusual and that the USPS would still be protected from most claims related to mail issues, even if the Supreme Court sides with her client.

She emphasized that this lawsuit arises from exceptional circumstances

: Konan asserts she was the victim of systemic racial bias and suffered financial losses, including missed rental income after tenants left due to undelivered mail. The case also brings attention to broader issues of postal service responsibility, especially as more people depend on mail for essential items like medical supplies and legal paperwork.

The Supreme Court's ruling, anticipated in early 2026, is expected to have significant consequences for both USPS operations and individuals. If the Court rules in Konan's favor, the postal service may need to implement stricter controls over employee behavior; if the case is dismissed, the current legal protections for the agency against intentional misconduct claims will remain in place.

Legal experts such as Kevin Kosar

from the American Enterprise Institute believe the decision could depend on whether the Court chooses to limit the exemption's reach, weighing the importance of accountability against the potential for excessive litigation.

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

PoolX: Earn new token airdrops

Lock your assets and earn 10%+ APR

Lock now!

- Ethereum (ETH) struggles near $3,200 as mixed technical signals highlight crypto market fatigue, with the 50-day EMA at $3,468 acting as key resistance. - A block gas limit increase to 60 million aims to improve scalability, but price remains anchored near $3,000 amid broader sector weakness and Bitcoin's failed 50-day EMA retest. - Elevated whale deposits and negative ETF flows signal deepening corrections, with Ethereum mirroring Bitcoin's bearish pattern and Solana's 20% TVL drop amplifying sector fra

Bitget-RWA•2025/11/30 06:16

Ethereum News Today: Ethereum Faces $3,200 Test: Network Improvements Compete With Broad Market Downturn

XRP News Today: XRP's Upward Momentum Depends on Holding $2.10 Support Amid Emerging Structural Threats

- XRP surged 6.7% on Nov 25, 2025, trading between $2.195–$2.216 amid months of consolidation. - Technical indicators showed bullish patterns, including a V-shaped recovery and $5.12B trading volume signaling institutional interest. - Solana's $568M ETF inflows and XRP's derivatives activity highlighted shifting altcoin dynamics amid Fed rate cut expectations. - XRP faces $2.10 support test, with $2.30–$2.45 as key resistance, while structural risks like bearish moving averages persist.

Bitget-RWA•2025/11/30 06:16

XRP News Today: XRP's Upward Momentum Depends on Holding $2.10 Support Amid Emerging Structural Threats

LUNA Declines by 0.14% as Market Downturn Persists

- LUNA fell 0.14% on Nov 30 2025, extending its 82.52% annual decline amid crypto market weakness and structural shifts. - DTCC's tokenized collateral platform announcement highlights growing institutional blockchain adoption, though unrelated to LUNA's price action. - Tether's Uruguay exit due to energy costs and regulatory hurdles underscores operational challenges facing energy-intensive crypto projects. - Alt5 Sigma's leadership turmoil reflects governance risks in crypto firms, amplifying volatility c

Bitget-RWA•2025/11/30 06:08

LUNA Declines by 0.14% as Market Downturn Persists

Bitcoin Updates: Metaplanet Secures $130 Million Loan to Acquire Bitcoin, Pursuing 1% Supply Goal Despite Market Slump

- Metaplanet borrows $130M to buy Bitcoin , using BTC as collateral amid market downturn. - Funds will expand BTC holdings to 1% of total supply by 2027, mirroring Strategy’s approach. - Loan terms include floating rates and early repayment, with $2.7B BTC reserves as collateral. - Company also raises $135M via preferred shares, as Japan firms push crypto adoption. - Leaders remain bullish on long-term BTC value despite 20% unrealized losses and market volatility.

Bitget-RWA•2025/11/30 05:34